Article · 30 Jun 2025
Conference abstractPublished 3 Apr 2019
The Insanity of the insanity defense
Southern Federal University, Russia
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
If mental illness is culture-dependent and mostly serves as an organizing social principle - what should we make of the insanity defense (NGRI- Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity)? A person is held not responsible for his criminal actions if s/he cannot tell right from wrong ("lacks substantial capacity either to appreciate the criminality (wrongfulness) of his conduct" - diminished capacity), did not intend to act the way he did (absent "mens rea") and/or could not control his behavior ("irresistible impulse"). These handicaps are often associated with "mental disease or defect" or "mental retardation". Mental health professionals prefer to talk about an impairment of a "person's perception or understanding of reality". They hold a "guilty but mentally ill" verdict to be contradiction in terms. All "mentally-ill" people operate within a (usually coherent) worldview, with consistent internal logic, and rules of right and wrong (ethics). Yet, these rarely conform to the way most people perceive the world. The mentally-ill, therefore, cannot be guilty because s/he has a tenuous grasp on reality. Yet, experience teaches us that a criminal maybe mentally ill even as s/he maintains a perfect reality test and thus is held criminally responsible (Jeffrey Dahmer comes to mind). The "perception and understanding of reality", in other words, can and does co-exist even with the severest forms of mental illness. This makes it even more difficult to comprehend what is meant by "mental disease". If some mentally ill maintain a grasp on reality, know right from wrong, can anticipate the outcomes of their actions, are not subject to irresistible impulses (the official position of the American Psychiatric Association) - in what way do they differ from us, "normal" folks? This is why the insanity defense often sits ill with mental health pathologies deemed socially "acceptable" and "normal" - such as religion or love.
Ask about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.
Similar by topic
Article · 30 Jun 2025
The Role of Forensic Psychology in Insanity Defense Cases
Editorial · 30 Aug 2024
Forensic Mental Health and the Insanity Defense: Legal and Clinical Perspectives
Article · 3 Jul 2024
A Complex Legal and Ethical Dilemma in Insanity Defense
Mini review · 29 May 2023
Examining the Variables: Post-Mortem Dismemberment Cases and the Insanity Defense
Follow
New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.
- BylineArticles whose byline prints “Sam Vaknin”
