Scholars Central

Conference abstractPublished 2017

Rubrics versus marking guide for nursing students

Authors: Shahla Meedya, Carolyn Antoniou, Victoria Nevill

School of Nursing University of Wollongong, NSW, Australia

Ask about this article

Abstract

Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.

Background: Marking guides with checklist style and rubrics have been used in different tertiary institutions to prepare the students in demonstration of the learning outcomes in their assessment tasks. Some evidence demonstrates that checklist styles give a specific mark for each assignment criteria without challenging the students whereas, rubrics have been found to provide clear standards about expected performance in learning tasks. There is limited information about the students and academic markers experiences in comparing both the methods. Objective: The aim of the pilot study was to investigate the participant’s experience in using rubrics compared to the usual method of check-list style in their assessment tasks. Method: The study design was a quantitative and exploratory study in one of the tertiary institutions in Australia. Eligible participants were third year undergraduate nursing students (n=55) and employed academics (n=6) who marked the students’ assignments. Data was collected through online survey. The outcome measure was the participants’ experience in using rubrics and checklist style. Findings: Majority of the students (78%) were using rubrics for the first time, whereas they had used checklist marking guides for at least two years. Many of students reported that both rubrics and checklist marking guide were useful but they found rubrics difficult to understand, wordy, and repetitive. The academic markers feedback was not in favour of any specific method, but they found rubrics to be time efficient, clear, easy to moderate with other markers and easy to read in comparison to checklist style marking guides. Conclusion: Using rubrics was useful for the students to prepare themselves for the assessment task and it was time efficient and easy for the academic markers. However, the students need more education and support to understand and apply rubrics into their assessment preparation to achieve the full benefits of using rubrics.

Ask about this article

Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.

Try:

Similar by topic

Conference abstract · 4 Sep 2017

Nursing teachers teach and consult the next generation of nurses. They serve as role models for nursing students and guide students through the challenges that accompany them in learning to be a nurse (Greenwood, 2017). Nursing teachers provide instruction in the classroom and in some cases also work in clinical settings such as hospitals, clinics, and nursing homes. Most nursing schools also have clinical laboratories where students learn to perform basic nursing tasks such as managing medications, inserting catheters, giving injections and other hands-on skills, under the direct supervision of a nursing teacher. After the students have finished learning these skills they continue to the perceptorship, where they treat patients and perform the clinical skills taught in class under the supervision of the preceptor, who supervises trials and actual practice (Greenwood, 2017). The question is whether nursing teachers must have clinical experience as a nurse in the field, or is it enough for them to teach at nursing school? In this study I will present a discussion I held at a nursing school among the teachers on the role of nursing teachers and the essentialness of practice in the field, concurrent with their work as nursing school teachers. Another discussion held included a group of students as well. The purpose of the discussion was to examine the attitudes of those engaged in nursing and in nursing education with regard to the clinical effectiveness (clinical competence) of the nursing teacher and how it can be maintained and improved. The conclusions presented in the study, representing the personal attitudes of the teachers and students, offer educational and political recommendations for the national head of nursing.

More from this journal

The newest in Journal of Nursing & Patient Care.

All its articles

Conferences in this field

Upcoming conferences in this field.

Follow

New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.

  • JournalJournal of Nursing & Patient Care
  • SubjectNursing & Healthcare
  • BylineArticles whose byline prints “Shahla Meedya”
  • BylineArticles whose byline prints “Carolyn Antoniou”
  • BylineArticles whose byline prints “Victoria Nevill”

For authors and organisers

Publish, present and keep up with your field

Find the right journal for your paper and submit your manuscript.

Photo: Pexels