Commentary · 2021
ArticlePublished 24 Aug 2021
Uncertain Ground Research on Soil
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
The concept of “ecosystem” services of soils has received a lot of attention in the scientific literature and the media in recent years. The monetary valuation of these services is frequently depicted as a fundamental condition for the preservation of the natural capital that soils represent, as required by many countries and international organizations. This emphasis on soil services is set in the context of a broader interest in ecosystem services that began in 1997 and accelerated after 2005. The detailed review of the literature offered in this article reveals that interest in soil multifunctionality dates back to the mid 1960’s, Hundreds of experts around the world were trying, and mostly failing, to figure out how to place real price tags on “nature’s services.” Since then, soil scientists have worked to better understand the numerous activities and services of soils, as well as their possible links to critical soil properties such as biodiversity. They’ve also attempted to make progress on the difficult quantitative issues. However, researchers have shown little interest in monetary valuation, undoubtedly because it is unclear what economic and financial markets would do with prices for soil functions/services, even if we could come up with such numbers, and because there is no guarantee that markets would manage soil resources optimally, based on neoclassical economic theory. Instead of monetary value, the research has focused on decision making processes that do not require the systematic monetization of soil functions/services, among other things. Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) methods easily incorporate deliberative procedures involving a range of stakeholders, whilst Bayesian Belief Networks (BBNs) provide the extra benefit of allowing the effect of parameter uncertainty to be accounted for Participants must be extremely aware of the extreme relevance of soils to many parts of their everyday lives in order to progress in such public debates. We believe that, as long as this criterion is met, the combination of deliberative decision making procedures and a rigorous scientific methodology to quantifying soil functions/services (including uncertainties) is a highly powerful combination.
Ask about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.
Similar by topic
Opinion · 30 Jan 2025
Soil Science at the Crossroads: Why the Ground Beneath Us Deserves More Attention
Short communication · 29 Nov 2022
Contamination of Soil, Ground Water and Environment by Extraction of Uranium Mine
Perspective · 28 Sep 2022
Contamination of Soil and Ground Water by Chromium Toxicity
Research article · 3 May 2019
Ground Vegetation as Indicator of Soil Characteristics for an Ecological Site Classification of Southern Caspian Forests
More from this journal
The newest in Global Journal of Agricultural Economics and Econometrics.
Article · 24 Jan 2024
Economic efficiency of maize production: The case of West Hararghe Zone, Oromia National Regional State, Ethiopia
Research article · 29 Jun 2023
International trade of gum and resin (frankincense) in Ethiopia
Research article · 31 Jan 2023
Tef value chain analysis in western Oromia, Ethiopia: evidence from Tef producers and traders
Conferences in this field
Upcoming conferences in this field.
Follow
New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.
- JournalGlobal Journal of Agricultural Economics and Econometrics
- SubjectAgriculture, Food & Aqua
- SubjectBusiness & Management
- BylineArticles whose byline prints “John Gowdy”
