Scholars Central

Case reportPublished 14 Jun 2016

WHEN EXPERTS DISAGREE

Authors: Choon Leng Eu, Suarn Singh

ASEAN Journal of Psychiatry

Volume 17 · Issue 2 · Pages 1–4

Ask about this article

Abstract

Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.

Objective: The objective of this case report is to highlight some learning points behind the reasoning of the Appellate Court in a case where there were two different expert opinions by two forensic psychiatrists from two distinctive Malaysian Approved Psychiatric Hospital in regard to the soundness of mind of Mr. A for an alleged offence punishable by a death penalty. Methods: This case report is based on the reasoning of the Appellate Court in rejecting the plea of the prosecutor. Results: The High Court order remained in which the defendant was found not guilty due to reason of insanity (NGRI) provided by the Malaysian Law under Section 84 of Penal Code for the charge of dangerous drug trafficking, and he was ordered by court to undergo treatment for his underlying mental illness in a Psychiatric Institution under Section 348(1) of the Malaysian Criminal Procedure Code. Conclusion: In writing expert report, it is preferable to use a singular first-person pronoun in stating the conclusion. If there are other experts involved in either current or previous assessment, it would be beneficial to address their different opinions in the expert report. However, expert opinion is still an ‘opinion',’ and the court would be perfectly entitled to reject or differ from any of the expert opinions when there are proper grounds to do so.

Ask about this article

Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.

Try:

Similar by topic

More from this journal

The newest in ASEAN Journal of Psychiatry.

All its articles

Conferences in this field

Upcoming conferences in this field.

Follow

New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.

  • JournalASEAN Journal of Psychiatry
  • SubjectMental Health and Psychology
  • BylineArticles whose byline prints “Choon Leng Eu”
  • BylineArticles whose byline prints “Suarn Singh”

For authors and organisers

Publish, present and keep up with your field

Find the right journal for your paper and submit your manuscript.

Photo: Pexels