Short communicationPublished 31 Jul 2020
Sustainable Society 2020: Early Childhood Education
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
Thepurposeofthisresearchwastoexplorethedevelopmentofidentityandsocialinteractionswithinasecondgrade classroom.Specifically,genderwasatthefoundationofthisstudy.“Nooneisimmune.Sexrolesocializationanditseffectsare pervasive.Gendertraininghasbeenvariouslydescribedas“ubiquitous”,“omnirelevant”,and“primary”.Itmayalsobe inevitable.NochildseemstoavoidwhatZellaLuriareferredtoasthe“gendercurriculum”.Infact,typicallybyagethree,gender awarenessisferventlypresent,howeveritislikelythatgenderstereotypescanbemalleablewithadultinput.Assuchthisstudy specificallyinvestigatedthewayasecond-gradeteacherimplementedlessonsassociatedwithgenderstereotypeswithinthe regularcurriculum,inanattempttobeginimportantdiscussionsandthoughtfulnessrelatedtosex-rolestereotypes. Tocreateanidentityforoneselfistopositiononeselfintheworldaroundthem;tofindaplacewhereoneseemsto“fit”in ourcommunities,familiesandvastlycomplexsocialsystem.Ouridentitiesareconstantlyevolvingaspeople;bothadultsand childrengrowandchangewithtimeandnewexperiences,andtheiridentitiesare“constructedthroughtheintersectionofmultiple dimensions”.Forinstance,anysingleperson’sidentityisinfluencedbyamultitudeoffactors,includingrace,ethnicity,religion, sex,sexuality,gender,familylife,communityinvolvement,socialclass,language,physicalandmentalability,health,agency, perceivedpowerandability,andeducation.Theresearcherswererecentlytoldbyanelementarystudentthatsheidentifiesas “atomboywhoisdarkerthanbothof[her]parents”.However,thisidentityistransientandmaychangeovertime.Itisgenerally believedthatindividualshavecompleteagencytochoosetheirownidentities,especiallyinademocraticcountryliketheUnited Stateswherepeoplemaylovewhomevertheychoose,worshipinachurchesoftheirchoosing,andspeakfreely.Theseindividual freedomsmaymakeitseemasifouridentitiescanbemoldedentirelyonourown,butduetowaysinwhichaliberalsociety maystillostracize,excludeandphysicallyharmpeopledeemeddifferent,especiallyintermsofgender,individualsarelimitedin choosingtheiridentitiesundercircumstancesbeyondtheircontrol. Socialandculturalnormsdictatewhatnormalandacceptablebehavioris,andindividualsmustthendecidetoconformtothesenormstoacertaindegreeornot.Since“genderdevelopmentoccursinrelationtosomeoneorsomethingelse”studies haveshownthatchildrenlearnfromayoungagetointernalizegenderstereotypesthattheyareexposedtoathome,inthemedia, andfromteachersandpeersatschool.Itisdifficulttopinpointwhichinfluencemaybestrongestforyoungchildren,butina studyofAustralianfour-andfive-yearolds,maleandfemalechildrenwereabletowatchtelevisionclipsandsurmisethatmen wouldperformstereotypicallymasculineactivitiessuchasfixingcars,fightingfires,drivingtrucksandevenbecomingdoctors, whilemostchildrenguessedthatwomenwouldbetheonestosew,becomenurses,cookdinnerandwashdishes.Bothmale andfemalechildrenseemedtoholdamorerigidviewofmasculinity,fortheyansweredmoreoftenthatmenshouldcomplete thestereotypicallymasculinetasks,notbothsexes.Forthestereotypicallyfemaletasks,morechildrenansweredthateither womenorbothsexesmightcompletethetasks.Whenaskedabouttheirownabilitiestoperformeachofthesetaskswhenthey grewupiftheysodesired,four-year-oldchildrenofbothsexessawthemselvesascompetentinbothgenderedsetsoftasks,but five-year-oldfemalesexpresseddoubtthattheywouldbeabletoperformthemorestereotypicallymasculinetasksiftheywanted to.Thisresearchsuggeststhatyoungchildrenalreadyholdstrongideasaboutwhatmasculinityandfemininityentailbythetime theyenterkindergarten.Five-year-oldfemaleshavealreadyreceivedmessagesastowhichpartsofsocietytheirsexisexcluded from,as“theseparticipantsfeltthatsomemasculineactivitieswerenotlikelytobewithintheircompetence”.Identityformation istherebylimitedinchildren,astheylearntonavigate“oppressiveandexclusionarysystemsofgender”. Eventhelanguagethatchildrenhaveavailabletodefinethemselvesintermsofgenderisextremelylimiting,asitfitsa rigid,binaryconstructofgenderthatforceschildrentochoosetoeitherbea“she”ora“he”.Almostallchildrenaregivena biologicallyassignedgenderatbirth,eveniftheyarebornintersex.Becausewestillliveinasocietywheretransgender,gender nonconformingandintersexpeopleareoftennotgrantedtherightsthattheydeserve,identityformationcanbeaverypainful processforchildrenwhoidentifyoutsideoftherigidconstructsthatwehaveofsexandgenderinoursociety,particularlywhen ourlanguagemayexcludethemfrombelongingtoarecognized,acceptedsocialgroup(i.e.“typical”boysandgirls). Significantly,inourcurrentsociety,nochildisimmunetowhatZellaLuriatermedthe“gendercurriculum”,whichimplicitly teachesandreinforcessex-rolesocialization.Adultsimposegenderonchildrenbeforetheyareevenborn,astheyanxiouslyask expectingparentswhichsextheirbabywillbe,andpresentthemwithpinkclothesforbabygirlsandblueclothesforbabyboys. Adultswillalsopickupgenderedtoyswhenplayingwithmaleandfemaleinfants,andoftenfeeluncomfortablewithknowing howtoaddressbabiesifthesexisnotimmediatelydiscernable.Thishasstrongimplicationsforteachersandparents,who mustbecomeawareofgenderstereotypesthattheyhaveinternalizedandfightagainstthesebiases,andstrongimplicationsfor childrenandstudents,whomustbetaughttorecognizeandactivelycounterthenegativeattentionthatgendernonconformity receivesinourworld.Examplesofgenderstereotypesthatchildreninternalizebeforeandshortlyafterenteringschoolinclude thefactthatbeingagirloraboycomeswithachecklistofthingsonemustdo“right”,andcompletingtheseitemsmakesitmore likelythatachildwillbetreatedfavorablybypeers.Forinstance,ayoungmalechildlovestowearpinkandcarrypurses,butthe nightbeforebeginningkindergarten,heswitcheshispinkcrocsoutforbluecross.
Subjects
EducationAsk about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.
Follow
New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.
- JournalEducational Research
- SubjectEducation
- BylineArticles whose byline prints “Aref A. abou-ali”
- BylineArticles whose byline prints “Armeen R. BAmeen”