Scholars Central

Journal and publication policies

Editorial policies

Who decides what is published, how review is run, and what happens when something has to be corrected.

Who decides

Every decision on a manuscript is the journal's editor's. Neither the platform nor anybody who has paid a fee, sponsored a conference or bought an advertisement has any part in it, and no editor may decide on a manuscript they have an interest in (see publication ethics).

Each journal sets its own scope, article types and review model; its page here states them. Where a journal's own policy is stricter than this page, the journal's applies.

Peer review

Manuscripts are reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with no conflicting interest in the work. Most journals here are single-blind (reviewers know the authors; authors do not know the reviewers); a journal that is double-blind says so on its page and asks for an anonymised file.

Reviewers are asked to judge the work and not the author, to declare any interest before they accept, and to treat the manuscript as confidential. Nothing under review is shared, cited or used by a reviewer before it is published.

Decisions

A decision is one of four, and it is sent to the corresponding author with the reviewers' comments:

  • Accept. No further change is needed.
  • Minor revision. Specific changes; usually one more round with the editor alone.
  • Major revision. Substantive changes; usually back to the reviewers.
  • Reject. Either out of scope, or the conclusions are not supported by the work.

A manuscript returned for revision has a date by which it is expected. After that it may be treated as a new submission.

Appeals

Write to the journal's editorial office within 30 days of the decision, saying which part of the review you believe is mistaken and why, point by point. The editor who made the decision does not decide the appeal alone. An appeal is not a second submission and does not reopen review unless the editor finds the first one was flawed.

Screening on arrival

Every submission is checked when it arrives for completeness, structure, missing declarations and overlap with work already on Scholars Central. These checks are advice for the editorial office. They are not a decision, and nothing about a manuscript changes because of them.

Some of that screening uses AI, and no AI system makes or recommends a decision on a manuscript. The AI policy sets out what runs on arrival, what runs only with the author's consent, and what is never sent anywhere.

Corrections, retractions and the version of record

The published article is the version of record. Where something in it is wrong, the record is corrected in public and the original stays reachable:

  • A correction for an error that does not change the conclusions.
  • A retraction where the findings are unreliable, whether through honest error or misconduct. The article stays online, marked as retracted, with the reason.
  • An expression of concern where there is a serious question that is not yet resolved.

An article is never quietly changed or removed. If a record here differs from the journal's own published version, tell us through Something wrong on this page? on the record, and we will check it.

Identifiers and indexing

A published article is identified by its address here and by the journal's own reference number. The publishers do not operate a DOI registration service, so no part of this platform promises a DOI. Where a journal is indexed somewhere, its own page says which index; we do not claim indexing on a journal's behalf.

Editorial policies · Scholars Central