Scholars Central

Journal and publication policies

Publication ethics

What we expect of everybody who writes, reviews or edits here, and what happens when it is not met.

Authorship

An author is somebody who has done all four of these. Everybody who has done all four is named:

  1. made a substantial contribution to the design of the work, or to acquiring, analysing or interpreting its data;
  2. drafted the paper or revised it critically for its intellectual content;
  3. approved the version to be published;
  4. agreed to be accountable for the work, including for questions about its accuracy raised after publication.

Anybody who helped without meeting all four is thanked in the acknowledgements, with their agreement. Paying for a study, heading a department and supplying materials are not by themselves authorship, and neither is writing a paper for somebody else to sign.

The author list is settled before submission. A change to it after submission needs the written agreement of every author, including the one being added or removed, and the editor's.

Originality and duplicate submission

A manuscript must be your own work, not published before, and not under consideration anywhere else. A preprint, a thesis and a conference abstract do not count as prior publication, but declare them at submission.

Quote with quotation marks and a citation; reuse your own earlier text no more freely than anybody else's. Submissions are checked for overlap with work already on Scholars Central and against manuscripts under consideration elsewhere on it.

Conflicts of interest

Declare anything a reader could reasonably think affected the work: funding, employment, consultancy, shares, patents, paid speaking, and a close personal or professional relationship with somebody who could benefit. Declare it even where you are sure it changed nothing.

Funding is named in the paper with the grant number, and the funder's part in the work is stated — including, where it is true, that the funder had none.

Reviewers and editors declare theirs too, and step aside where one exists.

Data and images

Keep the data behind the paper and be ready to show it. An image may be adjusted for brightness or contrast across the whole image; nothing may be added to, moved within or removed from one, and lanes or fields from different experiments are not combined into one figure without saying so.

AI in writing a paper

An AI tool is not an author: it cannot be accountable for the work. Where you have used one in writing or in analysis, say so in the methods or the acknowledgements, naming the tool and what it did. You are responsible for every sentence you submit, including for anything an AI tool made up. What the platform itself uses AI for is set out in the AI policy.

When something is alleged

Tell the journal's editorial office, or write to us, with what you have seen and where. We take allegations seriously whoever makes them, and we do not pass a complainant's name to the person complained about without asking.

The editor puts the concern to the corresponding author and gives them a fair chance to answer, usually within 14 days. Where it is not resolved, the matter goes to the authors' institution. Where the published record is affected, it is corrected or retracted in public (editorial policies), and the reason is given.

Publication ethics · Scholars Central