Article
AN EXPLORATORY STUDY OF DIFFERENCES IN STUDENTS’ VIEWS OF THE MARKET SYSTEM
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
This study examines data gathered in an anonymous in-class survey of first-year university students regarding the perception of markets. The study employs a survey instrument developed by Lephardt and Breeden (2005). The purpose of the study is two-fold. First, the study investigated the existence of differences in the perception of the role of markets along gender lines. This study found that although male students generally had a more favorable impression of markets, only token statistical evidence was found for the existence of these differences. Second, the study investigated the existence of differences in the perception of the role of markets by major field of study. This study found the existence of differences in the perception of markets to be somewhat striking. THE SURVEY INSTRUMENT AND ASSOCIATED MATERIAL This study uses the survey instrument (Market Attitude Inventory, MAI) developed by Breeden and Lephardt (2002) and Lephardt and Breeden (2005). The 2002 paper was an empirical study that used a survey instrument first developed by the authors in 1992 and refined over the next decade. The 2002 study involved 406 student responses in three different economics courses during two time periods (1992 and 1999). The authors found “significant differences in attitudes between demographic subcategories and between classes of students, as well as changes in attitudes over the time elapsed” (Breeden and Lephardt 2002, 154). The 2005 study provides the development and underpinnings of the survey instrument used in the 2002 paper. In many ways, the methodology set forth in the Lephardt and Breeden study of 2005 preceded the 2002 study. The authors noted two factors that motivated them to develop the MAI. One factor was a longterm research agenda involving “the evaluation of the relationship between an individual’s attitudes toward the market system and achievement of economic success within that system” (Lephardt and Breeden 2005, 63). The second factor was the absence of any valid survey instrument “that measured the values and attitudes people hold toward the market system” (Lephardt and Breeden 2005, 63). The survey instrument has two sections. The first section of the survey requested demographic data from the individual respondent. Specific questions pertained to the respondent’s gender, age, ethnicity, and major field of study. The second section of the survey instrument was a slightly modified version of the MAI developed by Lephardt and Breeden (2005). The original MAI had 22 statements that measured attitudes towards the market system. For each of the 22 statements, students were asked on the survey instrument to “indicate your level of agreements to each statement by writing a number between Journal of Economic and Economic Education Research, Volume 15, Number 3, 2014 Page 122 ‘0%’ and ‘100%’’ for the statement, with ‘0’ indicating “strongly disagree” with the statement and “100%’ strongly agree with the statement. Some of the statements portray a positive slant towards a market economy and some portray a negative slant towards a market economy (Thomas and Campbell 2006, 33). The 22 statements in the MAI are prefaced with the clause “In my opinion, the market system in the U.S. …” (Lephardt and Breeden 2005, 68). Breeden and Lephardt found “students in more advanced business classes having the most pro-market attitudes” (Breeden and Lephardt 2002, 169). However, since this study focused on first-year students, and first-year students, with minimal exposure to either business or economics in the high school curriculum, might focus on the word “market” in the introductory clause and lose sight of the study’s emphasis. Consequently, it was decided that the introductory clause be massaged to read “In my opinion, the economic system in the United States:” (emphasis added). The wording of the 22 statements, however, did not change from the original MAI. Five additional statements that relate to the role of the federal government in a market-based economy were introduced. Hence, the wording of the introductory clause to these five statements (23-27, inclusive) was revised to read “In my opinion, the federal government of the United States should:” All 27 statements are listed in Table 1. Table 1 The MAI Survey Questions Situation/Scenario _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ In my opinion, the economic system in the United States: 1. … leads to an unfair distribution of income. 2. … rewards people fairly for their productivity and hard work. 3. … encourages unethical business behavior. 4. … leads to quality and technological advancement in products and services. 5. … leads to inadequate amounts of important public services (like police, roads, fire prevention). 6. … provides opportunities and incentives for success. 7. … encourages greed and excessive materialism. 8. … allows equal access to work opportunities. 9. … leads to erratic cycles of growth and then decline in economic activity. 10. … raises the living standard for most people. 11. … leads to monopoly power among businesses. 12. … leads to an efficient use of resources. 13. … encourages the abuse of he environment. 14. … leads to unemployment and worker insecurity. 15. … leads to excessive risk of business failure. 16. … requires a lot of government control to work well. 17. … allows too much foreign competition. 18. … provides consumers the goods and services they want. 19. … provides employment opportunities for all who desire work. 20. … encourages innovation and the development of new businesses. 21. … provide goods and services at an affordable price. 22. “Overall, I believe that the economic system in the United States is a fair and ethical system.” In my opinion, the federal government of the U.S. should: Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, Volume 15, Number 3, 2014
Ask about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.