Scholars Central

Article

A CLASSROOM EXERCISE FOR TEACHING THE THEORY OF THE SECOND BEST IN A DUOPOLY SETTING

Ask about this article

Abstract

Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.

The Theory of the Second Best is an important proposition for students of public policy and economics. It states that, when markets are characterized by imperfections, efforts to enhance welfare by removing other imperfections can adversely reduce economic welfare. This article presents a simple classroom demonstration for teaching the Theory of the Second Best in an oligopoly setting. In the exercise, students represent firms in a duopoly choose a profitmaximizing price under specific market conditions. The results demonstrate that imperfect information and product heterogeneity, two market “imperfections,” make cartel coordination challenging and, thus, can enhance market performance. A description of a typical classroom discussion follows. The effectiveness of the exercise was tested by splitting a principles class into an experimental group and a control group. The results showed that the mean grade of students taught with the classroom demonstration was significantly higher than those taught by more traditional methods. I N TR OD U C TI ON The Theory of the Second Best (TSB) states that, when markets are characterized by imperfections, efforts to enhance welfare by removing other imperfections can adversely reduce economic welfare. Originally an insight emanating from general equilibrium theory (Lipsey and Lancaster, 1956), the TSB can also apply to partial equilibrium situations. A common example is of a mining monopoly where the output creates pollution -- an external cost on society. Breaking up the monopoly into many firms, an effort to remove one market imperfection could reduce overall welfare as the firms expand production and, therefore, create more pollution. Though often overlooked, this seemingly paradoxical effect on welfare makes the TSB an important concept for students of economic policy. The narrative common in most textbooks describes how the “ideal” state of perfect competition in a market economy optimizes economic welfare. Deviations from perfect competition are described as reducing economic welfare, requiring government intervention (Ragan, pp. 281-303). However, the TSB reminds students that care must be taken when prescribing policy. Simply removing a market imperfection does not guarantee enhanced welfare and could make the outcome worse. J.M. Clarke (1940) introduced the concept of a remedial imperfection - a deviation from perfect competition that improves the functioning of the market. 220 Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research Volume 16, Number 1, 2015 This article presents a simple classroom exercise for teaching the TSB to undergraduate students of economic policy. Using a duopoly setting, the exercise acts as an effective starting point for discussions on the concepts of market imperfections and cartel behavior. C LA S S R OOM EX ER C I S ES A N D D I S C U S S I ON This exercise is directed towards students who have completed a principles course in microeconomics (discussion questions are presented in italics). The class begins by asking students to recall the criteria of a perfectly competitive market. Collectively, students should have little difficulty remembering most of these, though (significantly for this demonstration) they may need to be reminded about the criterion of complete information. Students can also be reminded of the theoretical benefits of perfect competition towards economic welfare. Can you name a market that meets all of the criteria for perfect competition? Clearly, this is a challenge. While some markets may be close, students begin to realize that perfect competition is an unattainable ideal. Consider a market such as the automobile industry; what imperfections exist in this market? How about the airline industry (choose any well-known industries)? Students will recognize that these real markets are characterized by imperfections such as fewness, differentiated products, entry barriers, and incomplete information. The instructor informs the students that they will now participate in an exercise that will help them understand the difficulties of setting economic policy for imperfect markets. The students are grouped into pairs and told they will each represent a hypothetical firm in a duopoly. They will be presented with different scenarios; their objective in each is to maximize their individual firm’s profits. S cen ario 1 The first student, representing firm A, receives a cue card with the following information: Firm A Homogeneous Product Market Demand: Q = 1000 - 10p Your Firm’s Constant Marginal and Average Cost: MCA = ATCA = $15 Set your price to maximize your profits. No cooperation or communication. The second student, representing firm B, receives the following information: Firm B Homogeneous Product Market Demand: Q = 1000 - 10p Your Firm’s Constant Marginal and Average Cost: MCB = ATCB = $10 Set your price to maximize your profits. No cooperation or communication. 221

Ask about this article

Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.

Try:

Follow

New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.

  • SubjectEducation
  • SubjectPhysical Therapy & Rehabilitation