Article
COLLEGE FACULTY'S LABOR SUPPLY ELASTICITY: ESTIMATES USING SUMMER TEACHING STIPENDS
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
In this paper, we attempt to measure the impact of a significant – and likely permanent – wage cut on university faculty's labor supply decisions. Using data from a mid-size public university in Texas, we investigate how individual faculty respond to a cut in summer compensation (i.e., the per-course stipend for teaching summer classes). We find that the average (across faculty) reduction in the stipend was 26 percent, while the reduction in an average faculty's overall annual income (salary plus summer stipend) was only 3 percent. We find that the income effect of a cut in compensation (slightly) dominates the substitution effect, as faculty in general chose to teach more. We also calculate the resulting elasticity of the supply of summer teaching with respect to the stipend for every individual faculty in our data; while the values range from about -14 to 19.4, the average elasticity is negative and small in magnitude, suggesting that even a substantial cut in summer stipends causes only a small decrease in courses taught. BACKGROUND In 2011, Texas legislators were faced with a $27 billion budget deficit that they proposed to fix without raising taxes or using the state's rainy day funds (Mangan, 2011). In order to begin to close this gap, the Texas legislature proposed to make drastic cuts to higher education funding throughout the state. Specifically, colleges and universities were at risk of losing up to 7.6 percent of their state funding, and some onlookers worried that cuts could potentially displace many minority students and students in need of financial aid (Mangan). Hacker (2011) noted that mid-year 2011 lawmakers decided to cut state funding by about 7 percent for public colleges and universities for the 2012-2013 academic year causing staff layoffs and student tuition hikes. Although many colleges in the state continued to increase tuition and fees during this time, several institutions have sought to implement cost reductions such as decreasing spending on campus aesthetics. Other potential strategies included taking advantage of technology in the class rooms, offering more online classes, and increasing class sizes. At one public university, it was announced in early 2012 that to partially offset the budgets cuts, faculty pay for summer teaching would be reduced. Specifically, per-course compensation was changed from a fixed proportion of a faculty member's nine-month salary, to a series of stipends. Under the previous policy, full-time faculty members were paid 1/12 of their nine-month salaries per course. Table 1 shows the new compensation scheme for one course. Table 1: Compensation After the Budget Cut Nine-month Salary One-course Stipend Up to $41,999 1/12 salary $42,000 - $59,999 $3,500 $60,000 - $69,999 $4,000 $70,000 - $79,999 $4,500 $80,000 and over $5,000 In other words, the salary cut is progressive so that as salary increases, cuts increase as well. For example, if a faculty member earns $42,000 in income, her compensation both before and after the cut is $3,500 per course. However, if a faculty member has a $60,000 salary, her compensation is reduced by $1,000 per course, and if she has a $90,000 salary, the cut is $2,500 per course. In this paper we examine how faculty reacted to this cut in wages, including whether faculty members decided to teach more, less, or the same number of courses. In addition, the study will explore any systematic differences in behavior: for example, whether higher income earners reacted differently than lower income earners or whether there were any differences in behavior across genders or teaching disciplines. We also explore the relationship between faculty behavior and compensation vis-a-vis its relevance to the higher education community as a whole. Texas, like much of the United States, has had to tighten its budget due to the recent recession. Institutions of higher education have had to make difficult choices about how to increase revenues or decrease costs. Faculty response to a cut in summer teaching stipends – i.e., the elasticity of the supply of labor – is a crucial piece of information that administrators need to know to be able to predict the extent of actual cost savings of such a move. THEORY Economic theory has much to say about how wage changes affect a worker's willingness to work. Neo-classical labor supply theory describes a rational agent as making a choice between leisure, a normal good, and income, which can be used to buy goods and services in the market. Time spent working is compensated and translates into ability to buy more goods and services but necessarily leads to less leisure time. When wages change, workers are pulled in two separate directions. When a worker's wage decreases, the opportunity cost of leisure decreases as well and as the cost of leisure time has decreased, and workers will consume more leisure and work less. This is known as the substitution effect of a wage change. Simultaneously, a wage cut makes the same worker feel poorer as the new wage is unable to buy as many goods and services. This worker will consume less leisure and desire to spend more hours working. This income effect of a wage decrease pulls the worker in the opposite direction from that of the substitution effect. When it is impossible to separate these two conflicting impacts, a wage decrease can increase
Subjects
EducationAsk about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.
Follow
New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.
- SubjectEducation