Article
CONTRIBUTIONS FOR AN ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE ON SCHOOL CHOICE
Abstract
Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.
This paper provides an introduction to school choice analysis from the perspective of economics. The contributions from different fields and researchers are compiled and organized in a thematic manner. We first define the issue and highlight the advantages of an economic perspective. The brief history of the school choice debate is introduced and the most influential contemporary authors presented. We discuss several theoretical arguments both in favor and against school choice from the schools and districts perspective (supply side), and studentsparents view (demand side). The most important results from existing experiments are also summarized. We conclude there are two fundamental issues the analysis should incorporate: how information about school choice is disclosed to parents and schools, and how a proper evaluation about the programs is necessary. About the latter, we emphasize the necessity to select a proper control group and allowing enough time go by before analyzing the effectiveness of the programs being evaluated. JEL codes: I22, I28, A11, A12, H42 BACKGROUND Defining School Choice School choice refers to the freedom of parents and students to select the students’ form of education. While few would argue that our children ought not to be taught at all, the question of how we education our children is a much more pressing issue. Proponents of school choice tend to agree that parents and students should have more answers available to answer this question. In contrast, those arguing against this system find that making more schooling options accessible creates some larger net cost. While there are numerous models across the international educational system that claim to offer some form of “additional school choice” over the status quo, how these plans contribute to choice, if they do at all, vary greatly. It is therefore prerequisite to understand the jargon of the school choice debate before reviewing various policy models. It is our goal to provide an overview of the contributions for an economic perspective on school choice. Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, Volume 13, Number 3, 2012 Page 110 Currently, the typical methods by which parents select schools are choosing where to live (this determines the public school district to which they are a part of) or to attend a private alternative. Students receive education in one of four ways. In scenario (1), students are presented with privately financed and privately provided education (like private schooling or home schooling). Alternatively, in a different scenario, (2), students benefit from public financing but receive privately provided education (as is the case in school vouchers or charter schooling). In a third scenario, (3), students receive private financing to attend a publically provided school (this is more likely the case in tertiary education than in primary or secondary education). Finally, in (4), students attend a publically financed and provided school, such as the traditional public school. When compared to the situation in (4), more school choice implies a weaker governmental role. In (4), the government finances students’ education at public schools. The idea of offering more freedom in how parents select schooling for their children does not mean we should reduce the public endowment in any way (so long as we are careful to prevent financing from influencing provision) and thus a shift towards case (1) or (3) alone would not make sense. School choice can be offered by increasing private provision – a shift from (4) to (2) – or by a restructuring of the status quo of the public educational system – (4) to (4) – by creating some change that reduces current student and school restrictions. Regardless of whether we move from (4) to (2) or from (4) to (4) with restructuring, we maintain the idea of public provision, and thus are required to discuss the justifications for governmental intervention. Justifications for governmental intervention in a market tend to come from two concepts: efficiency and equity. The efficiency argument relies on the existence of market failures; hence, the government is the appropriate agent to step in and improve efficiency. Two important potential market failures in education are the existence of externalities or incomplete information. Because a student’s education increases their human capital (making them a more productive worker), education is commonly viewed as a positive externality. Given the education of a student creates an unrecognized or under-recognized benefit to society the government could justify intervention in the education market. A second important market failure is the problem of incomplete information. Parents and students are unable to measure properly the long-run value of education, which could lead to a less than optimal demand for education. The government’s role is thus to provide the necessary level of education. The government can also justify intervention in the education market because of equity. This argument is rooted in the idea that inequity of family resources between families should be corrected (e.g., families with greater resources have a higher ability to finance a private alternative or to choose to live in a better school district). Hence, this justification is more closely related to issues of public financing than of public provision. Either an inefficient or an inequitable market could justify the existence of public financing, though the debate is more intense over the issue of public provision. This explains why reactions are generally milder when considering a restructuring in scenario (4) to (4) than in moving from (4) to (2). Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, Volume 13, Number 3, 2012
Subjects
Business & ManagementEducationAsk about this article
Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.
Follow
New articles from what you follow go into your email digest, once you agree to alert emails.
- SubjectBusiness & Management
- SubjectEducation