Scholars Central

Article

GOLDILOCKS REBATES: COMPLYING WITH GOVERNMENT WISHES ONLY WHEN REBATE AMOUNT IS “JUST RIGHT”

Ask about this article

Abstract

Select any words in the title or abstract, or press this and choose a sentence.

While tax rate policy decisions are sometimes made to affect the economy in some specific way, the empirical evidence surrounding whether federal income tax refunds predominantly stimulate consumer spending or saving remains contradictory. This study attempts to combine income tax research findings with research on mental accounting, to determine if an explicit statement of how the government would prefer a refund to be used is effective in influencing taxpayers’ intended use of their refunds, controlling for the refund’s timing. The authors developed and administered an experiment, using college students as subjects, to test whether tax refunds with a stated government preference for spending or saving will be used. The study also explores the types of saving, consuming and investing (including the payment of credit cards vs. investments in securities, and the amount spent on durable goods vs. monthly expenditures) that result from refunds of different sizes under both a lump sum and a monthly distribution pattern, given different government preferences. A within subjects experiment of spending decisions was used, and ANOVA results confirm that government direction has only a very limited but significant effect on taxpayer spending and saving choices. Conformance with government preference appeared only in a “sweet spot” of rebate levels that is not too high in amount and not too low. This pattern would make sense where the friction costs of conforming with government preferences is viewed as relatively high for low rebate amounts - outweighing the benefits, as in the case of all (smaller) monthly rebated amounts and in this case, the $300/year amount. In 2008, the President and Congress enacted rebate legislation for the purpose of stimulating the economy with instructions for taxpayers to spend those refunds. To Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, Volume 10, Number 1, 2009 102 validate our initial findings, a second instrument was disseminated to test how taxpayers spent their actual lump-sum rebate checks. The same pattern was observed in the spending the actual rebates as predicted by the experimental study, supporting those experimental findings.

Ask about this article

Answers come only from this article's title, abstract and keywords, each sentence pointing to where it comes from. Your question is sent to OpenAI to write the answer. Scholars Central does not store it.

Try: