Every manuscript is checked automatically on arrival. Those checks are arithmetic and pattern checks: whether the required declarations are answered and internally consistent, whether the expected sections and files are there, whether the abstract and keyword counts are within the journal’s limits, whether the reference list parses and every entry is cited, whether the wording carries the signals research-integrity checks look at, and whether the text overlaps work already published on Scholars Central or another submission currently with us. These run on our own servers. Nothing is sent anywhere.
With the corresponding author’s consent, given at submission, we also ask a language model to write a report for the editor: a summary, a view on fit with the journal, strengths and weaknesses, suggestions and questions. The manuscript’s text is sent once, under a contract that forbids retention and training; author names, affiliations and contact details are not sent. Consent is optional and can be withdrawn.
No AI system makes or recommends a decision on this platform
An editor reviews the manuscript and makes a recommendation in their own words; the publisher’s admin approves. No manuscript’s status changes because of an automatic check or an AI-written report.
We do not use AI-detection software to judge whether a manuscript or a review was written by AI
Such tools are not reliable enough to be used against a person. We ask authors, reviewers and editors to declare any AI use instead.
Reviewers and editors must not put a manuscript into an AI tool of their own
A manuscript with us is confidential and unpublished. Do not put it, any part of it, or your own report into an AI tool of your own. If an editor or reviewer uses an AI tool in any permitted way, they must tell us.
Authors must declare their own AI use
Declare it at submission and in the manuscript: which tool, which version, and what it was used for. An AI tool cannot be an author, because it cannot take responsibility for the work. Authors are responsible for everything in their manuscript, including anything a tool produced.